Sub-Earth Planet Candidate Found at Nearby M-Dwarf, But Paper Includes Unusual Disclaimer
The paper reports a sub-Earth-sized transiting planet candidate (R≈0.70 Earth radii) around GJ 774 A, an M-dwarf just 12.86 pc away, based on repeated TESS transit signals across eight sectors spanning 2019-2026. The authors run extensive checks (odd/even transit tests, secondary-eclipse searches, PRF-deblended photometry, Gaia RV data) to rule out blended eclipsing binaries, concluding the signal most likely originates from the primary star A rather than its wide binary companion B, though the planet is not formally validated and some 2-3 sigma tension in the photometry remains unexplained. Twitter users highlighted and reacted with surprise to an unusual disclaimer in the text stating the author had not independently verified all analyses and lacked expertise to check every technical detail, with some questioning whether this violates arXiv's submission norms; this is being discussed as commentary rather than an established fact about the paper's validity.
Discussion: 3 tweets from 3 authors · @Dr_Dark_Matter_, @david_kipping, @AstroMikeMerri